Breast implants remain one of the most common cosmetic and reconstructive procedures worldwide. Whether for **augmentation**—to enhance size and shape—or **reconstruction** after breast cancer surgery or injury, implants provide options for people seeking changes in their appearance or rebuilding what was lost.
But before choosing an implant, it’s essential to understand the two primary types available: **saline-filled** and **silicone gel-filled implants**. Each has unique benefits, risks, and considerations that can influence your decision.
Saline vs. Silicone: The Key Differences
Although both types of implants feature a silicone outer shell, what sets them apart is their filling material and the way they feel.
Saline Breast Implants
Saline implants are filled with sterile salt water. Surgeons typically insert them empty and fill them once positioned inside the breast. This breast augmentation method can allow for slightly smaller incisions.
Key points about saline implants:
* Approved for individuals 18 years and older seeking augmentation.
* Used at any age for breast reconstruction.
* If they rupture, the saline solution is harmlessly absorbed by the body.
* Some patients find that saline implants feel less natural compared to silicone.
Silicone Breast Implants
Silicone implants are filled with a **thick silicone gel** that closely mimics the look and feel of natural breast tissue. Because of this, many patients prefer them for their more realistic appearance.
**Key points about silicone implants:**
* Approved for individuals **22 years and older** seeking augmentation.
* Available for reconstruction at any age.
* If they rupture, the gel may remain inside the shell or leak into surrounding tissue, making ruptures harder to detect without imaging. You will need a breast reconstruction specialist if this happens.
What Happens if an Implant Ruptures?
The effects of a rupture differ between saline and silicone:
* **Saline implants** deflate quickly, making the rupture visible within a short time. The saline is safely absorbed, but the implant will need to be replaced.
* **Silicone implants** may not show obvious signs of rupture. This is sometimes called a “silent rupture.” Because of this, routine MRI or ultrasound scans are often recommended to check for leaks.
—
## Risks and Complications
Like any surgical procedure, breast implants carry potential risks. The most common complications include:
* **Capsular contracture** – Scar tissue that hardens around the implant, altering its shape.
* **Breast pain or discomfort** – This may occur shortly after surgery or develop later.
* **Infection** – Though rare, infections may require implant removal.
* **Changes in nipple or breast sensation** – Often temporary, but sometimes permanent.
* **Rupture or leakage** – Leading to deflation in saline implants or silent rupture in silicone.
In some cases, additional surgery is required to **remove, replace, or adjust implants**.
—
## Rare but Serious Concerns
A small percentage of people with breast implants develop a condition known as **breast implant-associated anaplastic large cell lymphoma (BIA-ALCL)**. This is not breast cancer but a rare type of immune system cancer linked mainly to **textured-surface implants**.
Symptoms may include:
* Swelling around the implant
* A lump in the breast or armpit
* Skin changes over the breast
Although treatable—sometimes requiring surgery, chemotherapy, or radiation—early detection is crucial. For this reason, textured implants have been restricted or banned in several countries.
—
## Breast Implant Illness (BII)
Another growing concern is **breast implant illness (BII)**. Some people with implants report symptoms such as:
* Fatigue
* Memory issues
* Joint or muscle pain
Currently, there is no scientific consensus on the exact cause of BII. However, in some cases, symptoms improve after implant removal. Research is ongoing to better understand this condition.
—
## Making the Right Choice
Choosing between saline and silicone breast implants is highly personal. Your decision may depend on factors like age, desired look and feel, health history, and comfort with the risks. Consulting a **board-certified plastic surgeon** is essential. They can provide guidance tailored to your body type, lifestyle, and long-term goals.
Remember, breast implants are not lifetime devices. Over time, you may need additional procedures for replacement, adjustment, or removal. Regular medical check-ups and imaging tests are vital to maintaining breast health after implants.
—
### Final Thoughts
Breast implants—whether saline or silicone—can restore confidence, enhance appearance, and play an important role in reconstruction after illness or injury. Still, it’s important to approach the decision with **full knowledge of the benefits, risks, and long-term responsibilities**.
By understanding the differences between saline and silicone implants, being aware of possible complications, and working closely with your healthcare provider, you can make a choice that best fits your body and your future.
Article provided by Dr. Joel Aronowitz
